Nutley is a tidy, tree-lined Essex County township of roughly 30,000 set along the Third River between Clifton and Belleville, and we work it almost every week. Incorporated as a township in 1902 and built up as a rail-served bedroom community, Nutley developed along its topographical ridges — that's where planned neighborhoods like Nutley Heights, Prospect Heights, and Terrace Heights got their names — leaving the township with steeper, more detailed rooflines than the flatter cities around it. The housing is the story here: well-kept 1920s-1950s Tudors with steep pitches, center-hall colonials, and mid-century capes on quiet residential streets, shaded by mature street trees that fill valleys and gutters with debris. We handle the full range of roofing on these homes — full replacement and tear-offs, new roofs on additions and dormers, and the everyday repair and leak work that older period roofs need. We re-flash the tall masonry chimneys that stand on so many Nutley colonials, replace aging asphalt on capes due for their first or second roof, and detail the flat porch and addition sections that tie into the main pitched roof. We install architectural and designer asphalt shingle systems and we handle the low-slope membrane work where it shows up. We also do free post-storm inspections and walk homeowners through wind and storm-damage insurance claims honestly. We're Zubar Roofing & Exterior Systems, a family-run contractor based four miles south in Clifton — close enough for same-day leak response and same-week written estimates across all of Nutley.
Housing in Nutley
Predominantly 1920s–1950s single-family: Tudors with steep pitches, center-hall colonials, and capes, with mature street trees throughout. Steep-pitch work, detailed chimney flashing, and heavy valley debris from the tree canopy are the recurring themes.
What we most commonly find on Nutley roofs
- Steep Tudor and colonial rooflines that need experienced crews
- Tall masonry chimney flashing on period homes
- Heavy valley and gutter debris from mature trees
- Aging asphalt on mid-century capes due for first or second replacement
Roof Replacement & New Roofs in Nutley
When a Nutley roof is genuinely past saving, we do a full tear-off down to the deck, replace any rotted or delaminated sheathing — common under the original asphalt on 1920s-1950s capes and colonials — and rebuild a complete modern system: ice-and-water shield at the eaves and in the valleys, synthetic underlayment, proper intake and ridge ventilation, and new architectural shingles. Nutley's steep Tudor and colonial pitches and cut-up rooflines take real crew experience to tear off and re-lay cleanly, especially around the tall masonry chimneys and the valley intersections that the township's homes are full of. We also do new-roof installation on additions, dormers, and the back-of-house bump-outs that show up on these period homes near Memorial Park and through the Yanticaw section. Every replacement is quoted in writing, line by line, so you can see exactly what you're paying for.
What a Nutley roof replacement costs depends on the things we can only judge on site — the roof's size and pitch, how cut-up the roofline is, how many valleys, chimneys, and penetrations have to be flashed, the condition of the decking once we're in, the shingle tier you choose, and how tight the access is on a tree-lined street. A steep, detailed Tudor with two masonry chimneys is a very different job from a simple cape, which is exactly why we don't quote roofs over the phone. We come out, measure, inspect, and hand you a free written, itemized estimate. As GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed certified contractors, we can also register the enhanced manufacturer system warranties most one-off Nutley roofers can't, on top of our own 10-year transferable workmanship warranty in writing.
On permitting: a like-for-like shingle re-roof on a detached one- or two-family Nutley home is generally treated as ordinary maintenance under New Jersey's Uniform Construction Code, so it usually doesn't need a construction permit. New decking or framing, a new dormer or skylight, or any three-family or larger building changes that and requires a permit. We confirm the specifics with Nutley's construction office and pull whatever applies — you don't have to chase it.
Roof Repair & Leak Repair in Nutley
Most of what we get called for in Nutley is repair, not replacement — and on a well-built period home that's usually the right answer. We track down active leaks, re-flash chimneys and sidewalls, replace cracked pipe boots and slipped or missing shingles, rebuild failed valley flashing, and seal the seams where a flat porch or addition roof ties into the main pitched roof. On an active leak we get a properly installed tarp up the same day in most cases — we're only four miles south in Clifton, so we're on a Nutley street fast. Emergency leak service is available 24/7 at (973) 337-9001.
Nutley's housing brings a predictable set of repair problems, and we've seen all of them. The tall masonry chimneys on the township's colonials and Tudors are a recurring leak source — original step-flashing and counter-flashing that's decades overdue, plus mortar and crown deterioration up top. The mature street trees that make Nutley so pleasant also dump leaves and seed into valleys and gutters, so water backs up, sits, and finds its way under shingles, especially in the steep valleys these rooflines create. And the heavy, wet snow and ice that the inland Essex County climate delivers in winter sets up ice dams along the eaves of older, under-ventilated roofs.
We'd rather fix a roof than sell you one you don't need, and we'll prove it with photos either way. If your roof has real life left, we make the targeted repair and tell you honestly how many seasons it likely has. If it's genuinely at the end of its life, we'll show you why on the same photos and lay out replacement as an option — never a hard sell. Either way, the inspection and the written estimate are free.
Shingle Roof Contractors Serving Nutley
Shingle roofs are the backbone of Nutley's housing stock, and asphalt shingle work is the core of what we do here. We install GAF, Owens Corning, and CertainTeed architectural and designer systems — lines like GAF Timberline HDZ, Owens Corning Duration, and CertainTeed Landmark — chosen for the township's four-season, freeze-thaw climate and matched to the look of the home. On a steep 1930s Tudor or a center-hall colonial near Yanticaw Park, the right architectural or designer shingle keeps the period character intact; on a clean mid-century cape, a straightforward architectural upgrade is usually the smart, durable call.
Being certified with all three major manufacturers matters more than it sounds. It lets us register the enhanced manufacturer system warranties — the long-term coverage that depends on a credentialed contractor installing the full system correctly — which most one-off roofers simply can't offer. We pair that with proper ice-and-water shield at the eaves and valleys, balanced attic ventilation, and our own 10-year transferable workmanship warranty in writing. On Nutley's steep, detailed pitches, the install details are what separate a roof that lasts from one that leaks in five years, and that's where an experienced crew earns its keep.
Flat & Low-Slope Roofs in Nutley
Nutley is mostly a pitched-roof township — that's the dominant work here — but flat and low-slope sections do show up, and they're built and detailed differently than shingle roofs. The common ones are rear porch roofs, sunroom and addition roofs, and the occasional low-slope bump-out on the older homes around Franklin Avenue and the Yanticaw section. These are membrane systems, not shingle, and the leaks almost always start at the same place: the tie-in where the low-slope section meets the main pitched roof.
We install and repair welded-seam TPO, EPDM rubber, and modified-bitumen low-slope roofs, and we detail the flashings, drainage, and pitched-to-flat transitions correctly so that seam stops being the weak point. Because so much of Nutley's flat-roof work is a small section attached to a larger pitched roof, we handle both on the same visit — re-roofing the porch in membrane while the main roof gets shingles, all in one coordinated, written scope. If you've got a flat porch or addition that's pooling water or leaking, we'll inspect it free and tell you straight whether it needs a repair or a new membrane.
Storm Damage & Insurance Claims in Nutley
Nor'easters and summer convective storms regularly bring high winds and heavy, wet snow across Essex County, and Nutley's steep, exposed rooflines and tall chimneys take the brunt of it. Those same heavy rainstorms are what drive the Third River flooding the township knows well — Nutley sits low in the watershed before the Third River empties into the Passaic, and spots like the Passaic Avenue area go under in a bad storm. After a storm, we do free roof inspections, document every bit of damage photo by photo, and meet your adjuster up on the roof so legitimate wind, hail, and impact damage doesn't get under-counted.
We handle the insurance side in plain language and on the level. We never ask you to sign an AOB (Assignment of Benefits), and we never waive or 'eat' your deductible — both are improper and illegal in New Jersey, and any contractor offering to do either should be a red flag. What we do is document the damage thoroughly, give you a clear written, itemized scope, and stand with you so the claim reflects what actually happened to your roof. If you think a recent storm hit your Nutley roof, get a free inspection before you file — call (973) 337-9001.
Why we work in Nutley
Nutley is a 10-minute drive south, and its period homes reward the careful, detailed roofing we specialize in.
Familiar landmarks
Memorial Park · Yanticaw Park · Third River
Nutley neighborhoods we roof
We work every corner of Nutley — The Enclosure (Enclosure Historic District), Yanticaw section, Nutley Heights, Prospect Heights, Terrace Heights, Memorial Park area, Yanticaw Park area, and Franklin Avenue downtown / business district — across all 1 ZIP codes (07110).






